Just Pies Menu
Apple
Fresh Delicious apples piled and packed in our flaky, home-made crust. This is a double crust pie.
$40
Banana Cream
Special Order , Please give us 48 hours to make this fabulous pie for you. Made-from-scratch, banana cream filled with chunks of bananas and topped with heavy whipping cream. No instant pudding found in this pie!
$34
Banana Pudding Cheesecake
Our amazing baked cheesecake that is baked in a graham cracker crust lined with vanilla wafers. Then we top it with our in-house, made-from-scratch, banana cream, bananas and sweet whipped topping and a final touch of more vanilla wafers. Ooohhh sooo gooood!
$43
Buttermilk
Our grandmother's recipe from way back. Old fashion buttermilk pie with a "pinch" of nutmeg added in. This filling is then poured into our signature flaky crust and baked to perfection.
$30
Buttermilk Coconut Pecan - Award Winner!
2019 Taste of Tyler Award Winner!! This is our Buttermilk pie with a twist. We use our buttermilk recipe and add sweet coconut and yummy pecans, all poured into our signature flaky crust. Now available in sugar-free (select that option)
$32
Butterscotch Meringue
Home-made Butterscotch filling, made from scratch with all the brown sugar yumminess, poured into our signature flaky crust and pilled high with meringue.
$30
Caramel Apple Cheesecake
Sweet cinnamon apples fill the base of this yummy cheesecake, and then topped with caramel apples and pecans. Talk about A Taste of Fall!!
$39
Caramel Crème Brûlée
A fun take on Crème Brulee'. We make our own caramel cream filling and that's the first layer in our signature crust. Next, we top it with our own vanilla cream filling and then sprinkle with sugar and Brulee' (caramelize) the sugar to a hard brittle top. What a treat for the taste buds!
$32
Caramel Meringue
Home-made caramel filling, made from scratch with all the brown sugar yumminess, poured into our signature flaky crust and pilled high with meringue.
$30
Cheesecake
Old-fashion "baked" cheesecake. Our cheesecakes are baked in a graham-cracker crust and topped with a yummy sweetened sour cream. Please select if you would like a cobbler or fruit-topped cheesecake.
$31
Cherry
We make our own cherry filling with a hint of almond flavoring, poured into our signature flaky crust and topped with a lattice-work top crust. AVAILABLE IN SUGAR-FREE.
$40
Cherry Crumble
Now this one is so amazing! Our own yummy cherry pie filling poured into our signature flaky crust and topped with a brown sugar/butter crumble - all browned to perfection.
$40
Chess
What is a chess pie? We get this question often. This pie originated from England. It is a custard-style pie with a browned topping. It contains a small amount of buttermilk and believe it or not, a scant amount of corn meal. Mix all that together for a very sweet treat - all poured in our signature flaky crust.
$30
Chocolate Buttermilk
An old-fashioned buttermilk pie with cocoa added in and baked to perfection in our signature flaky crust. A yummy gooey middle with a very thin "crinkle" crust.
$30
Chocolate Chess
What is a chess pie? We get this question often. This pie originated from England. It is a custard-style pie with a browned topping. It contains a small amount of buttermilk and believe it or not, a scant amount of corn meal. Mix all that together with some rich cocoa for a very sweet treat - all poured in our signature flaky crust.
$30
Chocolate Espresso
Created exclusively for Just Pies by our granddaughter! An excellent blend of dark chocolate and Espresso, cooked to a rich creamy filling, then poured in our signature flaky crust and topped with heavy whipping cream, dusted with Espresso powder and topped off with chocolate covered Espresso beans.
$30
Chocolate Meringue
Mountains of meringue - Old fashion chocolate cream filling cooked to perfection - in our flaky crust.
$30
Chocolate w/ Whipped Topping
Our creamy chocolate filling in our signature flaky crust, topped with heavy whipping cream, chocolate shavings and a chocolate candy in the center! AVAILABLE IN SUGAR FREE AND GLUTEN FREE (GF in a GF chocolate graham cracker crust).
$30
Coconut Meringue
Mountains of meringue - Creamy coconut filling cooked to perfection - in our flaky crust.
$30
Coconut w/ Whip Topping
Our creamy coconut filling in our signature flaky crust, topped with heavy whipping cream and dusted with toasted coconut.
$30
Cookie Butter Icebox Cheesecake
Creamy cheesecake topped with Biscoff cookie butter cream and Biscoff cookies!
$36
Dubai Chocolate Pistachio Pie
Experience a delectable delight! A symphony of smooth Chocolate and crunchy pistachios enrobed in a delicate, flaky pastry. Treat yourself to a slice of Heaven today.
$35
Dutch Apple
Crispy Golden Delicious apples in our signature flaky crust, then topped with a brown sugar/butter crumble and baked to golden perfection!
$40
Egg Custard
This is our grandmother's recipe! Old-fashion Egg Custard is basically milk, eggs and sugar, a hint of nutmeg that bakes so smooth in our signature flaky crust. Most certainly an old southern favorite!
$29
German Chocolate
Gooey pecan brownie on the bottom layer, then topped with our smooth brown-sugar German chocolate, pecans and coconut topping! Rich, rich, rich!
$34
Hand Pies
Our own cream and fruit fillings baked inside our signature flaky crusts and topped with a sweet glaze! To order - you must order 6 of the same flavor as a minimum. Please specify quantity and flavor choices in the comments.
$28.50
Italian Cream Pie
Think Italian Cream Cake with cream cheese icing…but in a pie! Topped with a cream cheese whipped topping and garnished with sweet toasted coconut and toasted pecans!
$31
Kahlua Chocolate Brownie Cheesecake
Cheesecake infused with sweet Kahlua and poured over homemade brownies, topped with Kahlua chocolate ganache and finished with sweet Kahlua whipped topping!
$40
Key Lime - Best Seller!
OUR BIGGEST SELLER SINCE 2019! Creamy baked key lime filling poured into our signature flaky crust and topped with heavy whipping cream and lime zest. Gluten Free in a GF Graham Cracker Crust!
$33
Lemon Icebox
Cream lemon filling "baked" in our signature flaky crust. Topped with heavy whipping cream and a sprinkle of lemon zest. So refreshing!
$33
Lemon Meringue
Mountains of Meringue - Home-made creamy lemon filling - in our flaky crust!
$30
Millionaire Pie
Remember going to Grandma's and having the best fruit salad ever? Well, we've put it all in our signature pie crust for you. This has heavy whipping cream, maraschino cherries, pineapple and pecans (and a few other secret ingredients). So very refreshing! SEASONAL - MARCH - JUNE
$32
Mint Chocolate Chip
Creamy custard minty filling with mini chocolate chips and topped with sweet whipped topping, mint chocolate sprinkles and mint chocolate cookies!
$30
Nutterfluffer
This has become one of our most popular peanut butter pies! This has cream cheese, peanut butter, heavy whipping cream and marshmallow fluff all mixed together and piled into a graham cracker crust, then topped with heavy whipping cream and NutterButter cookies.
$32
Oreo Cheesecake
Creamy chocolate ganache baked into our yummy Oreo filled chocolate cheesecake - topped with another layer of chocolate ganache and Oreo cookies!
$34
Peach
We make our own sweet peach filling (no canned filling found here) and bake it in our signature flaky crust - with a top crust sprinkled with sugar! AVAILABLE IN SUGAR FREE.
$40
Peanut Butter Chocolate Lush
If you love peanut butter and chocolate - this pie is for you! We use our chocolate cream filling and mix it with cream cheese, heavy whipping cream and smooth peanut butter, pour it into a Oreo crust and then top it with chocolate whipping cream - and add a few Reese's peanut butter cups in the middle!
$32
Pecan
Old fashioned pecan pie in our flaky crust. We use chopped pecans. Oooey-gooey pie. We get raves about our pecan pie daily from our customers!
$32
Raisin
This delicious pie was Denise's grandmother's recipe. We take the plumpest raisins, a little citrus, brown sugar, nuts, and a few secret flavorings and bake all this yumminess in our signature flaky crust.
$34
Rhubarb
This has become one of our biggest fruit pie sellers! We can mix other fruits in it (strawberries, berries, cherries, etc) - just let us know your favorite! We cook our own fruit fillings and bake in our signature flaky crusts! Rhubarb is not always easy to find. As long as it is available , we will make it.
$40
Salted Caramel Whiskey Pecan Fudge Pie
Fudgy-gooey chocolate baked in our signature crust, then topped with a Whiskey-infused caramel and pecan mixture, then drizzled with chocolate ganache, shaved chocolate curls and sea salt, ending with a border of our sweet whipped topping!
$33
Samoa Spectacular
Like a Girl Scout Cookie but in a pie! Cream cheese filling on top of a caramel/coconut/pecan base, all in a chocolate crust.
$33
Strawberries And Chocolate
Nothing says I love you like fresh chocolate dipped Strawberries. Our yummy strawberry pie - filled with heart shaped strawberry slices and whipped cream garnish. Seasonal- February only unless special ordered.
$38
Strawberries And Cream
Yummy cream cheese and whipped cream filling with fresh chunks of strawberries added in, then topped with fresh sliced strawberries and a strawberry rose in the center. This is put in a graham cracker crust. Available Mid January - July
$35
Strawberry
Strawberry chunks swimming in this strawberry gelatin pie! We fill it up with strawberries. Then we top it with heavy whipping cream! AVAILABLE IN SUGAR FREE, Available Mid January -July
$29
Strawberry Rhubarb
This has become one of our biggest fruit pie sellers! We cook the rhubarb until it is soft and sweet and then we add chunks of sweet strawberries. This is all cooked in a double crust pie - of course with our signature flaky crust!
$40
Strawberry Roll
Light and fluffy vanilla cake filled with a creamy strawberry filling. Topped with our homemade strawberry jam, whipped topping, and fresh strawberries.
$30
The Big Easy (King Cake Pie)
If you love King Cake - you're gonna love The Big Easy! Cream Cheese filling, cinnamon, pecans, a praline center, poured into our signature flaky crust and topped with Mardi Gras sugar! Order mid January and March only.
$32
About Just Pies
Just Pies is here in Tyler, Texas
Denise Weaver has always had a passion for baking pies. As a girl, she felt most at home in the kitchen, learning to bake with the wonderful women in her family. Those childhood recipes have been refined and perfected by three generations of women who have a passion for baking their best into the Delicious Pies we serve today.
Just Pies is here in Tyler, and we are excited to bring our pies to your gatherings. Swing by Our Shop to meet us in person and try some of our famous treats!